The published evidence: a federal reporting review.

The U.S. Government Accountability Office published GAO-24-106764, Digital Experience: Agency Compliance with Statutory Requirements (opens in a new tab), on September 27, 2024; it was publicly released October 1, 2024. It examined digital-modernization reporting by 24 large federal agencies, concentrating on reports due in 2022 and 2023.

GAO tracked whether reports addressed eight modernization requirements. Across 192 possible agency-requirement entries per year, 84 were addressed in 2022 and 109 in 2023. Eighteen agencies submitted 2023 reports; seven addressed all eight requirements. Six agencies submitted no 2023 report, leaving their progress unknown.

Interpretation boundary: reporting coverage is not a direct accessibility test, a resident-satisfaction result or proof that a requirement was fully implemented. These are federal findings about historical reporting, not a survey of municipal websites or a 2026 market estimate.

What the research can tell a website buyer.

This brief uses a published government review as industry evidence. Civicfield Systems did not conduct the GAO study. The practical recommendations below are our interpretation for planning and evaluating public-service website work; the source does not endorse Civicfield Systems.

The useful distinction is between a broad promise and a reviewable record. “Modernize the website” leaves room for different interpretations. A project becomes easier to assess when each requirement has a defined scope, evidence to inspect, an owner and an acceptance decision.

That is a planning lesson, not a claim that a particular platform, vendor or workflow causes better outcomes. Local agencies also have different rules, budgets, systems and audiences from federal agencies. Determine applicable obligations with the responsible reviewers.

Close natural photograph of a report, marginal pencil notes and a separate website prototype on a laptop, suggesting careful interpretation of evidence rather than a claimed result.
Separating reporting evidence from implementation claims.

Turn a broad requirement into something you can inspect.

Project questionUseful evidence to requestWhere to start
Can people find a service?A representative task, observed steps, the barriers found and the changes reviewed.Redesign process guide
Is public content current?An inventory with responsible owners, source checks and unresolved decisions.Content audit workbook
Who approves an update?The exact draft revision, fact review, approval decision and publication check.Content calendar workbook
Will a redesign be accepted?Requirements linked to test coverage, deliverables, reviewers and handover records.Requirements scope builder

On a small screen, scroll the table sideways to see every column.

These examples are practical recommendations, not findings measured in the GAO study. They help a buyer ask for evidence suited to the work being purchased.

A buyer and service reviewer check a prototype and acceptance checklist against a source binder at a modest meeting table, candid realistic professional photograph.
Turning a project promise into inspectable evidence.

What this study does not establish.

  • It does not measure how many municipal websites meet a standard today.
  • It does not prove that a redesign reduces calls, saves staff time or increases trust by a particular amount.
  • It does not compare Civicfield Systems with other providers.
  • It does not predict results for a specific agency or project.

For implementation examples, inspect the owned community website projects, which are separate from the industry evidence. For a purchasing decision, review website design, content support or workflow tools against your actual requirements.